Your Crew
CAPTAIN Matt Neidlinger & MATE/CHEF Kari Compson
Captain Matt Neidlinger
Hi, I’m Matt—and I’m looking forward to welcoming you aboard. Before we meet in person, let me share a bit about my journey.
I grew up on the Mississippi River in northwestern Illinois, where boating, water-skiing, and fishing were part of everyday life. My parents instilled in me a deep respect for the water from an early age, and that connection has shaped everything since.
In 2005, I took a charter vacation in the British Virgin Islands—and it changed everything. The beauty of the Caribbean, the rhythm of life on the water, and the joy of sharing it with others sparked something permanent. Just a year later, I moved to the islands and began my career as a mate aboard a charter catamaran.
Seventeen years later, I’m still doing what I love. I’ve had the privilege of chartering throughout the Bahamas and the eastern Caribbean, and today, I’m proud to welcome guests aboard the Barefeet Retreat. Whether you’re eager to paddle, snorkel, hike—or simply relax and soak in the scenery—I’m here to help you make the most of every moment. I hold a 200-ton US Coast Guard License, am a certified ASA Sailing Instructor, and a PADI
Divemaster. More than anything, I’m passionate about creating unforgettable experiences on the water.
Chef Kari Compson
After more than two decades in corporate America, I traded boardrooms for blue water and never looked back. My journey into yachting began with a charter in the Grenadines, and that experience lit a fire in me. I earned my STCW certification and dove headfirst into the world of crewed charters, working in the Grenadines, Virgin Islands, and the Bahamas.
My first chef role was aboard a large motor yacht, but I quickly realized my heart belonged to smaller boats—where I could connect directly with guests and craft meals that truly elevate their experience. My cooking reflects my adventurous spirit and deep love for life on the water. I focus on fresh, wholesome ingredients and love weaving local flavors into every dish. I also understand the importance of dietary needs—having a food allergy myself—and I take great care to tailor menus to each guest’s preferences.
When I’m not in the galley, you’ll find me snorkeling, hiking, paddle boarding, or swimming in the turquoise waters. I can’t wait to welcome you aboard Barefeet Retreat and share the flavors, sights, and serenity that make this lifestyle so unforgettable.
January 2026
Captain Matt and Kari,
It has been an absolute pleasure sailing around the islands and laughing more and more as we went. Thank you for all the amazing meals, stories and game nights! This was a trip to remember forever, and we are so so grateful that you were a part of it.
Love, James and Allie
New Years 2025/26
An Experience Beyond Our Wildest Dreams:
We have just returned home from the most incredible trip touring the British Virgin Islands aboard the Barefeet Retreat, and we truly don’t have enough words to capture how extraordinary this experience was from start to finish.
From the very beginning, the booking and planning process was seamless and thoughtful thanks to [Broker] and her amazing team. Every detail was handled with care, professionalism, and genuine enthusiasm, which immediately set the tone for what would become an unforgettable journey.
And then there was Captain Matt and Kari, who, by the end of the trip, felt less like our crew and more like family. Saying goodbye at drop-off was genuinely emotional, complete with teary eyes all around.
Captain Matt curated the most perfect itinerary, taking us to breathtaking snorkeling sites, all the must-see locations, and anchoring us each evening in the most stunning, postcard-worthy settings. His knowledge, confidence, and passion for what he does were evident every single day. And as if that weren’t enough, his unexpectedly elite skills at “Rummy Cube” were greatly appreciated, and the laughter that filled the boat on our final night playing “Drop the Mic” was the perfect ending to a perfect journey. (Also, yes Matt can absolutely rock those 80’s tunes!)
Kari was equally incredible, joining in our shenanigans while somehow keeping us exceptionally well-fed throughout the trip. Every single meal was delicious, from her homemade oatmeal and granola to unforgettable wahoo and chicken dishes. Plates were cleared at every meal without exception. And the cookies and brownies? Let’s just say we’re still dreaming about them.
This trip exceeded every expectation we had. It was relaxing, adventurous, joyful, and deeply memorable. If you are considering a BVI sailing experience, do not hesitate, this team delivers something truly special. We will cherish these memories forever and cannot wait to return. ⚓️🏝️❤️